Thursday, 20 October 2011

Musical Analysis 8



Hello once again, everypony! It's sonic30 here with another song. So, after my last review, I got curious and decided to read the story Allegrezza. I liked it, and I recommend it, but it does begin to get some shipping as it goes along. Anyway, the story prompted me to be in the mood for some more Vinyl Scratch and Octavia stuff. However, I've done two songs that feature them together, and one of them was a bit Vinyl Scratch heavy. This time, I wanted to give a song about Octavia the spotlight.
The song this time around is "No Strings Attached (Octavia Battle Theme)" by Jeffthestrider. I picked this one mainly because I love battle music. This song is what Jeffthestrider believes Octavia's battle theme might sound like. I've gotta say, it's an interesting idea, but did the song turn out ok? Well, listen to the song and read up the review.
By the way, the review ran away and hid behind the page break. Careful! It's shy!

Ok, so the song begins with some temple blocks (That's what they are, right?) for the quiet intro. After a few seconds, some violins and a bass add in for a slow build up. (I think that's what they are. Don't be hating on my lack of string instrument knowledge. I know brass and drum set. Strings, not so much...)Still building up, a snare drum adds in with some rolls and single hits. With even more build up, some keyboard notes add in.
After a moment, everything but the keyboard, bass, and snare drop out, giving the keyboard a moment to shine. When the keyboard drops out, another (assuming) string instrument picks up the same lines that the keyboard was playing. Soon after, the violins jump in again, laying some chords on top of the music already there, then just as quickly takes over the melody.
Suddenly, the song drops in intensity, leaving room for some long note chords. However, everything else starts up again for another build up. Soon, a melody is established and repeats itself, adding more instruments on top of itself to add to the chord structure. When the melody begins to change, the keyboard comes back in to add more to the song.
After a bit more, everything but the keyboard and bass fall silent. The soft music still somehow manages to hold the tension of a battle while not getting fast paced or loud. Finally, it all fades out, leaving a few stacatto notes to end the song.
Overall, it's a nicely made battle song. Being a video game soundtrack buff, I listen to battle themes all the time. However, I've never really taken the time to consider ponies having RPG style battle music. Jeffthestrider has managed to pull it off, giving Octavia a respectable song for her fight to the death. (or not) I could easily see this being used in one of those fan made games that I've been tracking.

As explained above, my knowledge of actual instruments encompasses the brass section (I played trombone and baritone in marching band) and not the string section. My high school didn't even have string instruments (besides electric guitar for Jazz Band and a five string bass guitar) in the ensemble. If you know what these instruments are, please give me a heads up so I can correct my review. Thanks!

As always, leave any questions, comments, suggestions, requests, etc in the comments or in an e-mail. I love reading feedback, whether it's good or bad, so hit me with all you've got!

By the way, thank you to everypony who left me comments or e-mails wishing me a happy birthday! It means a lot to me. Also, at the request of Shanaar, I left a comment on the birthday post summing up Luna's performance. Check my comments here if you don't know what I'm talking about, or if you want to read about her song.

You guys are all awesome.
/)^3^(\

10 comments:

  1. Happy Birthday sonic30! Also, nice pick of song! That one's been on my iPod for a while now!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sigh, Sonic30. You are SOFT!

    You let those pesky reviews do what they want?
    Well I say NEIGH! Beat them into submission,
    BEAT THEM until they shout for attention, and then deny their appearance with a page break anyway.

    HA HAAA!

    That's what I do anyway...

    ReplyDelete
  3. @Soggy Doggy
    What? No! I could never hurt the poor reviews! They must be treated with love and affection, otherwise they might lie to our wonderful readers. That would be disastrous! Also, there would be so many letters and punctuation marks flung everywhere. It would make such an awful mess.

    @Matt Engel
    I'm glad you like it. It's good to hear that I'm not picking songs that nopony likes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It was your birthday and here you are, bearing gifts. 8^) Happy belated birthday!

    This work by Jeffthestrider has been in my favorites folder since it was released in July.

    Suggestions? How about a mind-blowing piano etude by Yourenigma, released October 17th and garnering 5,000 views in 25 hours?

    Or, there's FraGmenTed's Twilight Ethereal, also released on October 17 and all kinds of awesome (I need a larger vocabulary). I found the voice clips jarring at first, but I quickly adapted and now I find the song to be just about perfect.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Happy Belated Birthday, Sonic!

    To celebrate I bring you more Octavia and Scratch, this time with Applejack (for some reason) and a Mystery Pony (but really, you'll probably recognize her silhouette).

    I can't seem to find a youtube upload, and the flash sometimes loads wonky, so if it doesn't work at first, try again, the music is well worth it, and the animation is quite good too.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Oh my gosh I forgot to post the link. How embarrassing.

    http://lentoto.deviantart.com/art/Flash-MLP-Music-is-Magic-263314402

    ReplyDelete
  7. @Glomkettle
    Thanks for the link. It's a nice song, and the animation goes nicely with it. By the way, if you wait a bit, the "mystery pony" is revealed when she plays the guitar. Anyway, guess who's got that on loop now?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh, I know the mystery pony was revealed. I just didn't want to spoil it for anyone who hadn't seen it yet.
    And yeah, I looped it for an hour or two after I first found it. It makes nice background music for doing... just about anything, actually.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey! So you were pretty close to the instrumentation. Let me see if I can remember everything and clarify what the strings and synths are:

    The intro percussion to the song are woodblock and claves (I'm fairly certain, they're part of a whole suite of orchestral percussion sounds I have). The bell is a tubular bell. Then what you hear introduced is the cello, panned right, and then violins panned left. The bass is a synth I tried to make sound like a double bass before I found some awesome sound libraries. But I liked the sound of the synth so much I decided to keep it instead of using actual double basses. The keyboard is actually a synth called Atlantis. I was messing around and had managed to create a sound similar to the main melody line in the song "Planet Healer" from the Homestuck OSTs. So I just call it planet healer, hah. The strings that come in after the synth drops out are violins play plucked (pizzicato). Then when the solo violin comes in, there's also a cello accompaniment panned right.

    And then after that, it's just the bass synth and a flute for four bars, followed by some violins for another four.

    Percussion kicks back in, a new chord progression is established with the pizzicato strings, and the bass/flute/violin melody is repeated, until each instrument cuts out every four bars. A counter melody is introduced by the violins panned left at first and some trumpets follow four bars later. The violins cut out and some more instruments come in, mixing the melody up a little.

    Finally, it ends with the same atlantis synth repeating the melody near the beginning of the song. That ends and it's just the single pizzicato string instrument playing some quarter notes so it can make the song loopable.

    Anyways, that's what's going in the song. Cool review and thanks for the compliments!

    ReplyDelete
  10. @Jeffthestrider
    Ok, two things. 1) Ohmygoshohmygoshohmygosh! I knew that we had some of the composers actually visiting this site, but I now have approval from you on the review! Thanks, Jeffthestrider!
    and 2) When I asked for help with the instruments, I was expecting somepony to just help me guess, but I never expected the one who made the song to actually clear it all up for me! It's a good song, and I'm glad you liked the review.
    /)^3^(\

    ReplyDelete